Melbourne is one of the most vibrant and exciting cities in Australia, renowned for its dynamic arts scene, world-class restaurants, and passion for sport. However, the best of Victoria lies beyond the city limits, from the stunning coastal scenery of the Great Ocean Road to the serene wineries of the Yarra Valley. The way you choose to travel can define your entire experience, so it is important to weigh up your options.
This guide compares Melbourne’s extensive public transport network with the freedom and flexibility of car hire, helping you decide which is the best choice for your trip.
Why the Way You Travel in Melbourne Matters
Your choice of transport has a significant impact on your holiday. Public transport is perfect for a budget-friendly trip focused on Melbourne’s inner city, while a hire car gives you the freedom to create a unique adventure across the entire state.
Getting Around with Public Transport
Melbourne’s public transport system, managed by Public Transport Victoria (PTV), is a well-integrated network of trams, trains, and buses. It is a fantastic option for exploring the inner city.
The Advantages
- Affordable Ticketing: Melbourne uses the Myki card, a reusable smart card that you can top up with credit. A full fare daily cap for metropolitan travel is $11.00, meaning you can travel as much as you like on a single day without being charged more.
- Free Tram Zone: Trams within the Central Business District (CBD) are completely free. This makes it easy and cost-effective to sightsee, visit landmarks like Federation Square, or explore popular shopping strips like Bourke Street Mall without using a Myki card.
- Extensive Network: With hundreds of routes, you can reach almost any inner-city suburb or major attraction, including sporting venues like the Melbourne Cricket Ground (MCG) and museums.
- Environmentally Friendly: Public transport is a great choice for reducing your carbon footprint.
The Limitations
- Fixed Schedules: You are bound by timetables, which can be a hassle if you have an early morning flight or want to stay out late at night. Services can also be less frequent on weekends and public holidays.
- Overcrowding: During peak hours, trains and trams can be very crowded, making it uncomfortable if you are travelling with luggage or children.
- Limited Access: While the metropolitan network is extensive, it offers limited access to the true “hidden gems” of regional Victoria. Destinations like the Great Ocean Road, the Dandenong Ranges, and the Mornington Peninsula are difficult, if not impossible, to reach efficiently using public transport.
Exploring Melbourne with Alpha Car Hire
For travellers who value flexibility, comfort, and the freedom to explore at their own pace, car hire is the superior choice.
Benefits of Car Hire
- Total Freedom: With a car, you can create your own itinerary and visit multiple attractions in a single day. You can stop whenever you like to take photos, grab a coffee in a quaint country town, or simply enjoy the scenery.
- Access to Regional Victoria: A car is essential for experiencing the best of Victoria. You can drive the iconic Great Ocean Road, spend a day wine tasting in the Yarra Valley, or discover the beauty of the Dandenong Ranges.
- Comfort and Privacy: Unlike public transport, you can travel with your family or group in the comfort of your own space. It is also the ideal solution for carrying luggage, sports equipment, or shopping without any hassle.
Alpha Car Hire’s Commitment to Quality
Alpha Car Hire is committed to providing a great value service in Melbourne. Our branch is located at 157 Mickleham Road, Tullamarine, a short distance from the airport.
- Modern, Well-Maintained Fleet: We offer a diverse fleet of new and well-maintained vehicles, from fuel-efficient economy cars to spacious SUVs and people movers.
- Affordable Rates with No Hidden Fees: Our off-airport location allows us to offer competitive rates. You can also enjoy unlimited kilometres on most passenger vehicles, giving you the freedom to explore without worrying about extra charges.
- 24/7 Roadside Assistance: For your peace of mind, all our rentals come with 24/7 roadside assistance for mechanical breakdowns.
- Free Airport Shuttle: We provide a free shuttle bus service from Melbourne Airport (MEL) directly to our branch, making pick-up and drop-off simple.
Cost Comparison: Car Hire vs. Public Transport
| Travel Option | Daily Cost (Approx.) | Best For |
| Public Transport | $10–$20 per person | Solo travellers, short city trips |
| Alpha Car Hire | From $35–$60 per day | Families, groups, regional travel |
The Practicalities of Car Hire in Melbourne
Driving in Melbourne is a unique experience. Being prepared for the city’s specific road rules and infrastructure will help ensure a smooth journey.
- Melbourne Tolls: The city has a network of cashless toll roads, including CityLink and EastLink. All Alpha Car Hire vehicles are fitted with an e-tag, which automatically records your toll usage. The tolls will be charged to your card after your rental, along with a small administration fee. You can use the official Linkt toll calculator to help plan your costs.
- Hook Turns: A unique feature of Melbourne’s CBD, hook turns are a right-hand turn made from the left lane. This is done to keep cars clear of the tram lines. Watch for the “Right Turn From Left Only” signs and follow the road markings carefully.
- Parking: Finding parking in the CBD can be a challenge. We recommend using a parking app like Wilson Parking or Parkhound to pre-book a spot. For longer stays, look for “early bird” specials at multi-storey car parks. Always check parking signs carefully for time limits, especially in clearways.
Where a Car Hire Wins Hands Down
A hire car is undoubtedly the best option for specific types of trips and destinations.
- The Great Ocean Road: A car is essential to experience this world-famous drive. Take your time to stop at key landmarks like the Twelve Apostles, Gibson Steps, Loch Ard Gorge, and the Grotto. You can also explore the inland beauty of the Great Otway National Park.
- The Yarra Valley: A hire car allows you to visit multiple wineries and attractions at your own pace. You can enjoy a tasting at renowned estates like Yering Station or Domaine Chandon, stop for a gourmet lunch, and then visit the Healesville Sanctuary to see Australian wildlife.
- Flexibility and Convenience: Avoid the hassle of lugging heavy luggage or sports equipment on and off public transport. A car is perfect for families with prams, business travellers with multiple bags, or anyone planning to do a lot of shopping.
Choosing the Right Option for Your Trip
- Choose Public Transport if: You are a solo traveller or a couple, your travel is primarily restricted to Melbourne’s CBD, or you are on a very strict budget.
- Choose Car Hire if: You are travelling with a group or family, you plan to explore regional Victoria, or you want the flexibility to set your own schedule. This is often the best choice for a more comfortable and adventurous holiday.
A Hybrid Approach
For the best of both worlds, consider using a hybrid approach. Use the Free Tram Zone and a Myki card for your initial sightseeing in the city, then pick up your hire car for a specific day trip or a longer regional journey. This gives you the convenience of both options.
Tips for Booking with Alpha Car Hire
We want your booking process to be as smooth as possible.
- Book in Advance: To secure the best rates and your preferred vehicle, especially during peak seasons, we recommend booking your car hire well in advance via our booking form.
- Choose the Right Car: Think about your group size and luggage. A compact car is great for city trips, but an SUV or a people mover might be a better fit for a family road trip.
- Understand Your Coverage: Our protection packages allow you to reduce your excess liability. Read through our terms and conditions to choose the best option for you.
Book Your Melbourne Adventure with Alpha Car Hire
Ready to explore Victoria on your terms? Alpha Car Hire makes it easy with a simple online booking process and a commitment to quality service.
Book Your Melbourne Car Hire Today
You might also be interested in our other travel guides, such as our advice on getting the Best Value Car Hire in Sydney and our Gold Coast Airport Car Hire information.
